Pastors
James A. Gloucester
1849-1851
Amos N. Freeman
1852-1860
C. H. Thompson
1860-1863
Amos N. Freeman
1864-1885
W. H. Dickerson
1886-1887 (stated supply)
W. H. Dickerson
1887-1892 (installed)
W. R. Lawton
1892-1895
William Alexander
1896-1915
J. E. Harper
1915-1917 (stated supply)
J. E. Harper
1917-1919 (installed)
George Shippen Stark
1919-1947
Milton A. Galamison
1948-1988
Sylvester L. Shannon
1990-2001
Glen C. Missick
2001-2003 (stated supply)
Darryll H. Young
2004-2013
Eric A. Thomas (stated supply)
2017-current